Coaching or Consulting? Why the Boundaries are Becoming Increasingly Blurred - And What Psychologists Can Do About it
- Irion Dekov
- Jun 10
- 3 min read
Author: Anna Brand
In today's economy, the traditional boundaries between coaching and consulting are becoming increasingly blurred. What was once considered clearly separate disciplines is now evolving into a hybrid approach that includes both advisory and supportive elements. For psychologists, this opens up an opportunity to use their expertise in different contexts.
The traditional separation of coaching and consulting
Traditionally, consulting has been seen as an expert role, providing expertise and specific solutions to organizational problems. Consultants analyze processes, identify weaknesses and recommend methods for improvement. In contrast, coaching focuses on the personal development of the client. A coach helps people to find their own solutions, promote self-reflection and achieve personal goals. This distinction can be traced back to different approaches: Consulting is more solution-oriented and directive, while coaching is more process-oriented and non-directive.
The gradual blurring of roles
However, these clear dividing lines are becoming increasingly blurred. In reality, companies are faced with complex challenges that require not only technical expertise but also human understanding. Similar to these challenges, hybrid solutions must also be found in which consultants and coaches act together. One example of this is business coaching, which combines both advisory and supportive elements to promote professional development.
New role models: The reflective sparring partner
With the merging of coaching and consulting, a new role model is surfacing: the reflective sparring partner. This role combines specialist knowledge with the ability to self-reflect and emotional intelligence. Psychologists in particular are well suited to this position, as they have both analytical skills and a deep understanding of human behavior.
The reflective sparring partner is not only a problem solver, but also a companion in the change process. This role supports clients in developing their own solutions, promotes self-confidence and helps them to navigate complex situations.
Tradition meets transformation: an example from practice
Let's briefly compare the traditional approach with our new role model:
In the „classical“ consultant role, a consultant presumably presents a finished strategy, with ready-defined targets and a concrete action plan - based on the assumption that the main problem is of a structural or procedural nature. The focus is on the “what” and the “how”.
Example from the financial sector: When introducing a new digital customer portal, the traditional consultant would deliver KPI-based targets for increasing efficiency and user retention, for example, without sufficiently taking into account employees' concerns about automation or job loss.
In the role of reflective sparring partner, on the other hand, the conversation is conducted on a different level. The aim here is to work with the manager to find out why the situation is stuck, what inner blockages exist, how the team reacts on an emotional level - and what personal development areas arise from this. Instead of providing ready-made answers, questions are asked to build trust. Although the consultant contributes her experience, she does so in a process- and relationship-oriented manner. The result is not only a better strategy, but also a stronger leader.
Example from the tech industry: A software company that wants to become more agile benefits from a coach-consultant who not only explains scrum roles, but also reflects with the CTO executive on their leadership style - for example, why they find it difficult to relinquish decision-making power.
This comparison shows: The reflective approach is not a rejection of professionalism or a lack of specialist knowledge - but an extension. Psychologists bring their full potential to bear here - through their professional, human and systemic skills.
Opportunities for Coaching Psychologists
This role development offers numerous opportunities for psychologists:
- Expanding the field of activity: By integrating coaching elements into counseling, psychologists can apply their expertise in new contexts.
- Strengthening their position in the company: As reflective sparring partners, they can play a key role in transformation processes and contribute to the development of a positive corporate culture.
- Promoting personal development: The combination of coaching and consulting enables psychologists to continuously develop their skills and acquire new competencies.
Conclusion
The boundaries between coaching and consulting are becoming increasingly blurred, creating new roles and opportunities for psychologists. As reflective sparring partners, they can provide both advice and support and thus make a valuable contribution to the development of individuals and organizations.
コメント